My blog has moved!

You should be automatically redirected in 6 seconds. If not, visit
http://www.farwestchina.com
and update your bookmarks.

Monday, February 23, 2009

New Kashgar Dress-Code Requires "All-Chinese" Look

I used to work at a summer sports camp years ago named Kanakuk that required strict dress code for its employees, a code which they referred to as the "All-American Look".  Clean shaven, managed hair, no jewelry for men...you get the picture.  Now I know that there are plenty of people who would find that discriminating, however I was aware of their requirements when I sought employment and I was perfectly content complying.  It was just part of the job.

I thought about that camp today while reading the news.  An article on RFA highlights a new point of contention in the always restless (although not necessarily dangerous) region of Kashgar.  Here are the hairy details (pun...intended):
"Authorities in China’s westernmost city of Kashgar are stepping up pressure on government employees to go clean-shaven, and the city’s large ethnic Uyghur population, whose adult males overwhelmingly sport moustaches, aren’t happy about it, residents say."
In other words, the Kashgar government has instituted a strict "All-Chinese Look" in an area where minorities are actually the majority.  Not everybody has to shave, mind you, just the state employees.  It might be good to note that Chinese are notorious for being unable to grow good facial hair. 

I admit I'm having to take some time to think about this one!  It seems unfair and discriminatory, yet I didn't blink an eye when it was happening in America.  What's the difference and do these people have a right to complain?


Here's my quick take on it all: there are quite a few people who wouldn't want to be subjected to the dress code enforced by the camp I worked at, but I would venture to guess that most of those people aren't the types that should be working there anyway.  It sounds unfair, but some people have to go to work in a tie and suit or they get fired.  As long as these requirements are outlined and agreed upon beforehand, what's the difference?

Along that same train of thought, I have no problem with a city government asking for a specific dress code to be upheld - as long as it is outlined and agreed upon by all parties beforehand.  I can't make a judgment on whether or not that is the case here, as the person interviewed in the RFA article has a distinctly Uyghur name ("Tohti"), but I do have my doubts.  Controls have obviously been put in place in this area for a while now, and while this could be another one, it could just as easily be a government that wants its employees to look clean shaven.

What do you think?  Is this a fair or unfair requirement?

Source:
  RFA: Kashgar Uyghurs Pressured to Shave

1 Comment:

fred dintenfass said...

Great article. It's nice to see a balanced look at this kind of issue instead of just going off half-cocked about oppression and the like. Thinking about what it's ACTUALLY like in our home countries can be an important source of balance.

Post a Comment

Comment Guidelines:

  1. No profane or inappropriate language
  2. Links are allowed if pertaining to the subject at hand
  3. Links must be accompanied by a relevant comment

*Comments that do not abide by these guidelines will be deleted*

Blog Widget by LinkWithin