My blog has moved!

You should be automatically redirected in 6 seconds. If not, visit
http://www.farwestchina.com
and update your bookmarks.

Monday, March 09, 2009

Why Set Yourself on Fire? Story of the Self-Immolating Uyghurs (or Uzbeks?)

A week and a half ago a family of three Xinjiang Uyghurs - a mom, dad, and son - set themselves on fire in Beijing as an act of protest over a housing dispute.  At the time of the actual event, much speculation made its way around the internet as to the reason for this self-immolation but very few actual facts were known. Now, a week later, the details emerge.
 

In order to make way for the building of a new school back in 2002, government officials in a Xinjiang town informed this family that their home would be destroyed.  According to local officials, the family was offered two new houses (that's right...2), medical expenses for a mentally disabled daughter, and 400,000 yuan ($58,800) as compensation for their relocation.  I don't know about elsewhere in China, but here in Xinjiang that's a small fortune.

The official story states that the family didn't think this was quite enough.  They proceeded to make "unreasonable demands" for new jobs (Uyghur unemployment is among the highest in the world), an open apology, and fees covering their appealing visits to the government.  When these demands weren't met, they drove down to Wangfujing street in Beijing and set themselves on fire.  I mean, that's the logical next step in a minor appeals process like this, right?

If you're like me, you're thinking that something doesn't quite add up.  To make things even more confusing, these people were given first-class tickets to fly back to Urumqi on March 1st paid for by Urumqi's own government and are currently receiving burn treatment at a local hospital also on the government's dime.

I can't imagine anybody would willing set their entire family on fire over a job and an apology, so I'm tempted to believe the compensatory terms weren't originally that generous.  On the other hand, doesn't this send a message to would-be protesters that all they have to do to get attention is just set themselves on fire?
 
Two weeks ago these people were most likely poor and homeless.  Now they just took what might have been their first trip on an airplane, first class no less, back to two new houses and 400,000 yuan.

 
Update: It looks as if this story has another twist in store for us - the family might not have been Uyghur after all, but possibly Uzbek.  This doesn't really change the dynamics of the story much as both groups face similar obstacles here, but it's worth a note.  Thanks to Tim from McClatchy Newspapers for pointing this out to me.  He credited this original finding to the South China Morning Post which is hidden behind a pay wall.


Sources:
   The Straights Times: Set on Fire over Lost Home
   Xinhuanet: Three People in Beijing Self-Immolation Bid Have "Unreasonable Demands"
   RFA: Uyghur Moderate Speaks Out

9 Comments:

Anonymous said...

Josh, Do you actually work for CIA?

Anonymous said...

Sun, do you actually work for Sun Microsystems?

Anonymous said...

Your story seems different from Chinese medias. The Uzbek family occupied 35 houses(Their gradfather had 11 houses before 1959 but all were nationalized based on the then-policy.)

I show my sympathy for them. But the Self-Immolating is not acceptable.

Anonymous said...

@ Anonymous - Wow, I'd love to hear your sources because 35 houses seems like overkill in any country. If, however, this is true, don't you thinking losing a 12th house to "nationalization" would put you over the edge too?

I agree that self-immolating is an extreme measure, but that's the point - there's got to be something more to this story to bring them to this horrible decision, you know?

Anonymous said...

Josh, it should be 35 rooms, not 35 houses. Anyway, I donot know the details.

Anonymous said...

One fact you may not notice, there are 3 disabled persons in their 4-people family. I guess this is why they were very hopeless after losing their rooms.

Anonymous said...

@Anonymous - Thanks for pointing that out...I did notice that there were a few disabled persons in this family. The second house I mentioned in the post is for the disabled daughter. Some of the medical bills were (supposedly) paid, though, like I mentioned.

Stevo said...

Josh: What is the CIA pay for a blogger? More or less than an English teacher in China? Do they offer dental?

mohd said...

thank you for the all these info, now i know what have happened to all my Uyghur brothers and sisters in Xinjiang..

thank you so much..

Post a Comment

Comment Guidelines:

  1. No profane or inappropriate language
  2. Links are allowed if pertaining to the subject at hand
  3. Links must be accompanied by a relevant comment

*Comments that do not abide by these guidelines will be deleted*

Blog Widget by LinkWithin